Skip to main content
Ch. 5 - Chromosome Mapping in Eukaryotes
Klug - Concepts of Genetics  12th Edition
Klug12th EditionConcepts of Genetics ISBN: 9780135564776Not the one you use?Change textbook
Chapter 5, Problem 24

Traditional gene mapping has been applied successfully to a variety of organisms including yeast, fungi, maize, and Drosophila. However, human gene mapping has only recently shared a similar spotlight. What factors have delayed the application of traditional gene-mapping techniques in humans?

Verified step by step guidance
1
Understand that traditional gene mapping relies on controlled breeding experiments to track the inheritance of genetic traits across generations. This is straightforward in organisms like yeast, fungi, maize, and Drosophila, where researchers can control mating and produce large numbers of offspring in a short time.
Recognize that humans have unique challenges for gene mapping. One major factor is the ethical and practical impossibility of controlled breeding experiments in humans, which limits the ability to study inheritance patterns directly.
Consider the generation time in humans. Humans have a long generation time (approximately 20-30 years), which makes it difficult to study multiple generations in a reasonable timeframe compared to organisms with short life cycles like Drosophila or yeast.
Acknowledge the complexity of the human genome. Humans have a large genome with approximately 3 billion base pairs and a high level of genetic variation, which makes identifying specific genes associated with traits more challenging.
Factor in the smaller family sizes in humans compared to model organisms. Smaller family sizes reduce the statistical power to detect linkage between genetic markers and traits, making traditional gene mapping less effective in humans.

Verified video answer for a similar problem:

This video solution was recommended by our tutors as helpful for the problem above.
Video duration:
3m
Was this helpful?

Key Concepts

Here are the essential concepts you must grasp in order to answer the question correctly.

Complexity of Human Genetics

Human genetics is inherently more complex than that of model organisms like yeast or Drosophila. Humans have a larger genome with more genes, and the interactions between these genes can be influenced by environmental factors, making it challenging to map traits accurately.
Recommended video:
Guided course
06:51
Human Genome Composition

Ethical Considerations

The study of human genetics raises significant ethical concerns, including issues of privacy, consent, and potential discrimination. These ethical considerations have led to stricter regulations and a more cautious approach in applying traditional gene-mapping techniques to human subjects.
Recommended video:
Guided course
07:11
Mapping with Markers

Technological Limitations

Historically, the technology available for gene mapping in humans was less advanced than that used for other organisms. Techniques such as DNA sequencing and genetic markers have only recently become sophisticated enough to allow for effective mapping of human genes, contributing to delays in research.
Recommended video:
Guided course
07:56
Sex-Linked Genes
Related Practice
Textbook Question

An organism of the genotype AaBbCc was testcrossed to a triply recessive organism (aabbcc). The genotypes of the progeny are presented in the following table.

Answer part (a) again, assuming the three genes are so tightly linked on a single chromosome that no crossover gametes were recovered in the sample of offspring.

1296
views
Textbook Question

An organism of the genotype AaBbCc was testcrossed to a triply recessive organism (aabbcc). The genotypes of the progeny are presented in the following table.

What can you conclude from the actual data about the location of the three genes in relation to one another?

919
views
Textbook Question

Based on our discussion of the potential inaccuracy of mapping, would you revise your answer to Problem 22? If so, how?

605
views
Textbook Question

DNA markers have greatly enhanced the mapping of genes in humans. What are DNA markers, and what advantage do they confer?

734
views
Textbook Question

In a certain plant, fruit is either red or yellow, and fruit shape is either oval or long. Red and oval are the dominant traits. Two plants, both heterozygous for these traits, were testcrossed, with the following results.

Determine the location of the genes relative to one another and the genotypes of the two parental plants.

694
views
Textbook Question

Two plants in a cross were each heterozygous for two gene pairs (Ab/aB) whose loci are linked and 25 mu apart. Assuming that crossing over occurs during the formation of both male and female gametes and that the A and B alleles are dominant, determine the phenotypic ratio of their offspring.

1196
views