Skip to main content
Ch. 25 - Phylogenies and the History of Life
Chapter 24, Problem 15

Which traits do not correlate strongly with diversification rate within phyla, but are likely to have been important in the original diversification of animal phyla during the Cambrian? Select True or False for each trait. T/F presence of a head T/F mobile lifestyle T/F terrestrial lifestyle T/F bilateral symmetry

Verified step by step guidance
1
Step 1: The question is asking us to determine which traits do not strongly correlate with diversification rate within phyla, but were likely important in the original diversification of animal phyla during the Cambrian period. The traits given are: presence of a head, mobile lifestyle, terrestrial lifestyle, and bilateral symmetry.
Step 2: The presence of a head is a trait that does not strongly correlate with diversification rate within phyla. This is because many successful animal groups (like insects and mollusks) do not have a distinct head. However, it was likely important in the original diversification of animal phyla during the Cambrian period, as it allows for more specialized feeding and sensory structures. So, the answer for this trait is True.
Step 3: A mobile lifestyle is a trait that does not strongly correlate with diversification rate within phyla. This is because both mobile and sessile (non-moving) organisms can be highly diverse. However, it was likely important in the original diversification of animal phyla during the Cambrian period, as it allows for exploration of new environments and escape from predators. So, the answer for this trait is True.
Step 4: A terrestrial lifestyle is a trait that does not strongly correlate with diversification rate within phyla. This is because many highly diverse groups of animals are aquatic. However, it was not likely important in the original diversification of animal phyla during the Cambrian period, as this was a time when life was predominantly aquatic. So, the answer for this trait is False.
Step 5: Bilateral symmetry is a trait that does not strongly correlate with diversification rate within phyla. This is because many successful and diverse animal groups (like cnidarians and echinoderms) do not have bilateral symmetry. However, it was likely important in the original diversification of animal phyla during the Cambrian period, as it allows for more efficient movement and a streamlined body shape. So, the answer for this trait is True.

Verified Solution

Video duration:
2m
This video solution was recommended by our tutors as helpful for the problem above.
Was this helpful?

Key Concepts

Here are the essential concepts you must grasp in order to answer the question correctly.

Diversification Rate

Diversification rate refers to the rate at which new species are formed and existing species go extinct within a particular group, such as animal phyla. It is influenced by various factors, including environmental changes, ecological interactions, and evolutionary innovations. Understanding how certain traits impact diversification can help explain patterns of biodiversity observed in the fossil record and current ecosystems.
Recommended video:
Guided course
07:08
Metabolic Rate

Cambrian Explosion

The Cambrian Explosion was a significant evolutionary event that occurred around 541 million years ago, marked by a rapid increase in the diversity of life forms, particularly in marine environments. This period saw the emergence of many major animal phyla and the development of complex body plans. Traits that contributed to this diversification, such as mobility and the presence of a head, played crucial roles in the survival and adaptation of early animals.
Recommended video:
05:10
Cambrian Explosion

Key Morphological Traits

Key morphological traits, such as bilateral symmetry, the presence of a head, and lifestyle adaptations (e.g., mobile or terrestrial), are critical for understanding the evolutionary pathways of organisms. These traits can influence an organism's ecological niche, reproductive strategies, and interactions with other species. While some traits may not correlate strongly with diversification rates, they can still be pivotal in the initial phases of evolutionary development and adaptation.
Recommended video:
06:15
Origin of Complex Traits
Related Practice
Textbook Question

The vast majority of animals that ever existed are now extinct, but Tereza Jezkova and John Wiens wondered which variables were most important in driving the diversification of species that exist today. Why are there so many species in some phyla, such as Cnidaria (see photo), but so few in others, such as Ctenophora? Based on your reading of this chapter, propose at least five traits that you think might have been most important in triggering diversification within phyla (examples: origin of hearing, origin of internal fertilization).

396
views
Textbook Question

The vast majority of animals that ever existed are now extinct, but Tereza Jezkova and John Wiens wondered which variables were most important in driving the diversification of species that exist today. Why are there so many species in some phyla, such as Cnidaria (see photo), but so few in others, such as Ctenophora? Jezkova and Wiens used a type of graph called a linear regression to find correlations between variables such as the proportion of species per phylum with legs (on the y-axis) and the diversification rate per phylum (on the x-axis). Sketch a graph to show what a strong positive correlation between these two variables would look like and what the absence of a correlation would look like.

402
views
Textbook Question

The vast majority of animals that ever existed are now extinct, but Tereza Jezkova and John Wiens wondered which variables were most important in driving the diversification of species that exist today. Why are there so many species in some phyla, such as Cnidaria (see photo), but so few in others, such as Ctenophora? A sample of Jekova and Wiens' results is shown here. The R2 value represents the strength of the correlation (where 0.00 is lowest and 1.00 is highest). The P value represents the statistical significance. Which five traits look most important?

335
views
Textbook Question

The vast majority of animals that ever existed are now extinct, but Tereza Jezkova and John Wiens wondered which variables were most important in driving the diversification of species that exist today. Why are there so many species in some phyla, such as Cnidaria (see photo), but so few in others, such as Ctenophora? The researchers know that correlation does not equal causation. However, can the absence of a correlation enable you to reject a hypothesis of causation? How would the R2 values be different in a scenario where a single trait was important to diversification in many phyla versus a scenario where different traits were important to diversification in different phyla?

335
views