Skip to main content
Ch. 41 - Animal Nutrition
Chapter 40, Problem 14

Minnows are mainly carnivorous, eating insects and other small animals. However, herbivory has evolved independently in minnows several times. What changes in digestive structure and function are associated with the evolution of herbivory? Suggest a function of the difference in relative gut lengths of herbivorous and carnivorous minnows.

Verified Solution

Video duration:
59s
This video solution was recommended by our tutors as helpful for the problem above.
Was this helpful?

Key Concepts

Here are the essential concepts you must grasp in order to answer the question correctly.

Digestive Adaptations

Herbivorous fish, like certain minnows, exhibit specific adaptations in their digestive systems to efficiently process plant material. These adaptations often include modifications in the structure of the gut, such as an elongated intestine, which allows for increased fermentation and breakdown of fibrous plant matter. In contrast, carnivorous minnows typically have shorter guts suited for digesting protein-rich diets.
Recommended video:
Guided course
05:17
Digestion and Digestive Tracts

Gut Length and Diet

The relative length of the gut in fish is closely related to their diet. Herbivorous minnows tend to have longer guts compared to their carnivorous counterparts, as a longer gut provides more surface area and time for the digestion and absorption of complex carbohydrates found in plants. This adaptation is crucial for maximizing nutrient extraction from less digestible food sources.
Recommended video:
03:54
Interpreting Branch Length

Evolutionary Pressures

The evolution of herbivory in minnows is influenced by various ecological and evolutionary pressures, such as food availability and competition. When plant resources become abundant, certain minnow species may adapt to exploit these resources, leading to changes in their digestive structures. This evolutionary process can result in significant morphological and functional changes that enhance their ability to thrive on a herbivorous diet.
Recommended video:
02:45
History of Evolutionary Theory Example 1
Related Practice
Textbook Question

Minnows are mainly carnivorous, eating insects and other small animals. However, herbivory has evolved independently in minnows several times. What changes in digestive structure and function are associated with the evolution of herbivory? Like cichlids, minnows use their pharyngeal jaws to process food. Suggest some possible structural differences between the teeth on the pharyngeal jaws of carnivorous and herbivorous minnows.

511
views
Textbook Question

Minnows are mainly carnivorous, eating insects and other small animals. However, herbivory has evolved independently in minnows several times. What changes in digestive structure and function are associated with the evolution of herbivory? Which of the following is true of the digestive tracts of minnows? a. They are incomplete but have both a mouth and an anus. b. They are complete, facilitating compartmentalization of digestion in different organs. c. They are incomplete, with no accessory organs. d. They are complete and include a large gastrovascular cavity.

420
views
Textbook Question

Minnows are mainly carnivorous, eating insects and other small animals. However, herbivory has evolved independently in minnows several times. What changes in digestive structure and function are associated with the evolution of herbivory? Researchers compared the relative gut length—the length of the digestive tract divided by body length—in four species of herbivorous minnows and four species of carnivorous minnows. The results are shown in the graph provided here. Based on these data, what conclusion can you draw about the relationship between diet and gut length?

484
views
Textbook Question

Minnows are mainly carnivorous, eating insects and other small animals. However, herbivory has evolved independently in minnows several times. What changes in digestive structure and function are associated with the evolution of herbivory? Which minnows, herbivorous or carnivorous, should exhibit higher cellulase activity in the gut? Explain.

502
views
Textbook Question

Minnows are mainly carnivorous, eating insects and other small animals. However, herbivory has evolved independently in minnows several times. What changes in digestive structure and function are associated with the evolution of herbivory? Why did the researchers compare relative gut length instead of absolute gut length?

264
views