Skip to main content
Ch.19 - Chemical Thermodynamics

Chapter 19, Problem 14d

(d) Does the amount of work that a system can do on its surroundings depend on the path of the process?

Verified Solution
Video duration:
4m
This video solution was recommended by our tutors as helpful for the problem above.
617
views
Was this helpful?

Video transcript

Hey everyone today we're being asked which of the following options is true. And we're dealing with questions about the work performed by a system. Now let's think about this when work is being done by a system a certain amount of entropy will be created on the universe surrounding that system. For example, if we have, let's say water, we have water going from a liquid to a gas, good to a guest to a gas. The delta S of the universe will actually increase will increase. And this is because the randomness present in the universe as the liquid has become more excited is now more energetic in comparison will eventually increase the disorder or the entropy that is present in the universe. So with this in mind, if we think about it, if we have a reverse reaction that also happens or a reversible reaction then the delta S. Of the universe. The change in entropy of the universe will also revert, right? Let's try this in red. If we have the reverse reaction then delta S will revert. So by this logic we can actually say that a reversible pathway reversible pathway can accomplish the maximum amount of work because no entropy is actually lost to the universe. Because one way the reaction proceeds, entropy has increased and as it reverses the entropy decreases by the same amount. So the change in the entropy of the universe in a reversible pathway is zero. Right? So with that in mind, let's go ahead and look at our answer choices and we'll start from D. And work our way up. So it says that the amount of work performed by system on its surroundings is work dependent. Well this anti choice can immediately be ruled out. It doesn't really make sense. The work done by the system isn't dependent on the work that it outputs. It is simply a byproduct of the reaction that is happening. It is the amount of work produced by the reaction, not by the work itself. For answer choice. C. The amount of work performed by a system on its surroundings is not system dependent. Well this is also false. It is since independent right. We would need to have different systems in order to produce different amounts of work. For example. Again, looking at our water example, if we only have the forward reaction, let's say due to temperature only increasing, then the only this this part, the top part of liquid turning to gas will be part of the system. We won't be able to consider the reversible reaction in that case. So the work is actually dependent upon the system, which means that answer choice C. Is also incorrect. Now we're left to answer choices A and B. Where the work performed on the system on its surroundings as either path dependent or not dependent. And the answer to this will actually be A. And the reason for this is exactly as we described earlier when the path that is being taken either by external forces that are like temperature that are changing or pressure that is changing. If we have a reversible reaction, which is a type of pathway, that path will determine the amount of work that is performed right in a reversible reaction like this when gas becomes a liquid, the work and the change in entropy will decrease in comparison to a forward reaction. So the path dependency is a uh sorry. Path dependency is a principle or is something that work performed by a system needs to have. I hope this helps. And I look forward to seeing you all in the next one.
Related Practice
Textbook Question

Which of the following processes are spontaneous and which are nonspontaneous: (e) formation of CH4 and O2 molecules from CO2 and H2O at room temperature and 1 atm of pressure?

1390
views
Textbook Question

Which of the following processes are spontaneous?

a. the melting of ice cubes at −10 °C and 1 atm pressure

b. separating a mixture of N2 and O2 into two separate samples, one that is pure N2 and one that is pure O2

c. alignment of iron filings in a magnetic field

d. the reaction of hydrogen gas with oxygen gas to form water vapor at room temperature

e. the dissolution of HCl(g) in water to form concentrated hydrochloric acid

1082
views
Textbook Question

Indicate whether each statement is true or false. (a) A reaction that is spontaneous in one direction will be nonspontaneous in the reverse direction under the same reaction conditions. (b) All spontaneous processes are fast. (c) Most spontaneous processes are reversible. (d) An isothermal process is one in which the system loses no heat. (e) The maximum amount of work can be accomplished by an irreversible process rather than a reversible one.

931
views
Textbook Question

Consider the vaporization of liquid water to steam at a pressure of 1 atm. (a) Is this process endothermic or exothermic?

654
views
Textbook Question

Consider the vaporization of liquid water to steam at a pressure of 1 atm. (b) In what temperature range is it a spontaneous process?

443
views
Textbook Question

Consider the vaporization of liquid water to steam at a pressure of 1 atm. (c) In what temperature range is it a nonspontaneous process?

360
views