Skip to main content
Ch. 24 - Speciation
Chapter 23, Problem 11

A revolution in the study of human evolution is under way thanks to the invention of techniques that enable DNA sequencing of not only modern humans, but also ancient humans. Human populations today are not considered separate species under the biological species, morphospecies, and phylogenetic concepts. Explain what kind of evidence supports this statement.

Verified step by step guidance
1
Understand the species concepts: The biological species concept defines species as groups of interbreeding natural populations that are reproductively isolated from other such groups. The morphospecies concept identifies species based on morphological similarities and differences, while the phylogenetic species concept defines species as the smallest monophyletic groups on a phylogenetic tree.
Review genetic evidence from DNA sequencing: Modern DNA sequencing techniques allow scientists to compare genetic material from different human populations. These studies show high genetic similarity and extensive gene flow between populations, indicating they are not reproductively isolated.
Consider morphological evidence: Physical anthropological studies show that while there are some differences in morphology (physical form and structure) among human populations, these differences are not sufficient to classify them as separate morphospecies.
Examine phylogenetic evidence: Phylogenetic analyses of human populations using DNA data do not show distinct monophyletic groups that would classify populations as separate species under the phylogenetic species concept. Instead, all humans belong to a single monophyletic group.
Synthesize the evidence: The combination of genetic, morphological, and phylogenetic evidence supports the conclusion that all human populations today belong to a single species, Homo sapiens, under the biological, morphospecies, and phylogenetic species concepts.

Verified Solution

Video duration:
24s
This video solution was recommended by our tutors as helpful for the problem above.
Was this helpful?

Key Concepts

Here are the essential concepts you must grasp in order to answer the question correctly.

Biological Species Concept

The Biological Species Concept defines a species as a group of organisms that can interbreed and produce fertile offspring. This concept emphasizes reproductive isolation, meaning that members of different species do not typically mate or produce viable offspring. In the context of human evolution, this concept suggests that modern humans, despite variations, belong to the same species due to their ability to interbreed.
Recommended video:
03:24
Biological Species Concept

Morphospecies Concept

The Morphospecies Concept classifies species based on observable physical traits and morphology. This approach can sometimes lead to misclassification, especially in cases of convergent evolution or sexual dimorphism. In human evolution, while there are morphological differences among ancient and modern humans, these variations do not warrant separate species classification, as they share significant genetic similarities.
Recommended video:
03:24
Biological Species Concept

Phylogenetic Species Concept

The Phylogenetic Species Concept defines a species based on its evolutionary history and genetic relationships. It uses phylogenetic trees to illustrate how species are related through common ancestry. Recent DNA sequencing techniques have revealed that modern humans and ancient populations share a common lineage, supporting the idea that they are part of the same species rather than distinct ones.
Recommended video:
03:24
Biological Species Concept
Related Practice
Textbook Question

True or false? Speciation is a slow process. Justify your answer.

750
views
Textbook Question

Three-spine sticklebacks are small fish that originated in the ocean and continue to exist there, but then some took up residence in hundreds of streams and freshwater lakes in the Northern Hemisphere. Predict whether you would expect to find different species in lakes today.

418
views
Textbook Question

All over the world, natural habitats are being fragmented into tiny islands by suburbs, ranches, farms, and roads. If asked to join a science panel to speak to Congress, could you explain how this fragmentation process could lead to extinction? How it could lead to speciation?

337
views
Textbook Question

A revolution in the study of human evolution is under way thanks to the invention of techniques that enable DNA sequencing of not only modern humans, but also ancient humans. Before the application of DNA sequencing to fossils, which species concept was most useful for distinguishing human fossils? What is one disadvantage of this approach?

430
views
Textbook Question

A revolution in the study of human evolution is under way thanks to the invention of techniques that enable DNA sequencing of not only modern humans, but also ancient humans. Modern humans (Homo sapiens) and archaic humans called Neanderthals (H. neanderthalensis) shared a common ancestor in Africa but diverged in different geographic areas. When modern humans migrated out of Africa and dispersed around the world starting about 100,000 years ago, they overlapped with Neanderthals in Europe. This scenario is best described as a. species living in sympatry following allopatric speciation b. species living in sympatry following sympatric speciation c. species living in allopatry following allopatric speciation d. species living in allopatry following sympatric speciation

372
views
Textbook Question

Svante Pääbo and colleagues were the first to sequence the Neanderthal genome from fossils and compare the sequences to modern humans. According to the data shown here, did the two species interbreed when they overlapped in Europe? Explain.

461
views